Share this

What happened to social capital?

September 25, 2009

If you're like me, the phrase "bowling alone" conjures up vivid memories of undergrad sociology lectures about Robert Putnam and his popular 1995 essay. Putnam traced a decline in civic engagement to shifts in technology, including an increasing attachment to isolating media such as television and video games.

In a study about community attachment, you might expect social capital to play a big role. But two years of research have reinforced the finding that social capital isn't highly important in tying people to their communities. It was one of the drivers Gallup researchers studied, but it was low on the list of factors contributing to attachment.

Instead, researchers found a strong relationship between community attachment and social offerings (which includes the number and quality of local arts and entertainment venues). This means that what most determines a person's passion and loyalty to a place might not be whether they're bowling alone, but whether that bowling alley is a fun place to be.

From my understanding of Putnam's work, this finding doesn't necessarily contradict his research. "Bowling Alone" was less concerned with the relationship between people and their particular geographic communities, and more concerned with people's participation in democracy more generally.

Image courtesy of suzannelong on Flickr.

1 comment

[...] Here’s a link to the

[...] Here’s a link to the study’s website.The survey covered 14,000 Americans across the 26 Knight communities each year and asked questions about 10 key domains of community attachment: basic services like [...]

Please register or login to post a comment.

Discover the soul of your community

Great schools, affordable health care and safe streets all help create strong communities. But is there something deeper that draws people to a city – that makes them want to put down roots and build a life?

Latest SOTC Chatter

  • We visited Corpus Christi, Texas, last week for a presentation to the mayor and community. Here's how it went http://is.gd/rQrwwo #SOTC
  • Via Corpus Christi Caller Times: Soul of the Community presentation takes a look at value of place http://is.gd/7iLQ7e #SOTC
  • Attending the Soul of the Community meeting in #Corpus Christi tonight? Use the hashtag #SOTC. Comments on our Facebook http://is.gd/TE7N0H
  • Looking for more about the @Knightfdn Soul of the Community #Miami report? This short video summarizes http://is.gd/yz1jBK
  • Looking for the #Miami Soul of the Community report? Direct link here http://is.gd/trhqCe #SOTC
  • #SOTC study by @knightfdn presented in today's Miami-Dade State of the County address. Clip begins at 10m 50s http://is.gd/riT3BR
  • Openness, social offerings and education systems attach Detroiters to the city. Resident attachment in #Detroit http://is.gd/Pkj5Y5 #SOTC
  • Detroit feeling surge in local pride after Chrysler's "Imported from Detroit" Super Bowl ad stirs emotions http://is.gd/59fu9i #SB45 #SOTC
  • See our report on community attachment in #Detroit from the 2010 Gallup-Knight Soul of the Community study http://is.gd/f9tfwU #SOTC
  • .@ChryslerAutos #SB45 commerical "Imported From Detroit" impresses http://bit.ly/ChryslerSB45 #SOTC www.soulofthecommunity.org/detroit